7 Common Mistakes Cat Owners Make (And How to Fix Them)

7 Common Mistakes Cat Owners Make (And How to Fix Them)

Think you’re a purr-fect cat parent? Many of us believe we’re doing everything right for our feline friends, but even the most devoted cat lovers can fall into some common traps. Let’s explore seven mistakes that many cat owners make without realizing it—and more importantly, how to correct them for a happier, healthier relationship with your furry companion.

1. Forcing Cuddles or Holding

Picture this: You’ve had a long day at work, and all you want is to snuggle with your fluffy friend. But when you scoop them up for a hug, they squirm, struggle, and dash away the moment you set them down.

The Mistake: Cats are independent creatures who prefer affection on their terms. Picking them up constantly or forcing cuddles can actually damage the trust you’ve built with them.

The Fix: Let your cat initiate contact. When they do approach you, reward them with gentle pets, focusing on their cheeks, chin, and the base of their tail (spots most cats enjoy). Creating positive associations with human contact will make them more likely to seek you out for affection. Remember—earned affection is much more rewarding than forced interaction!

2. Only Having One Litter Box

You might think one litter box is sufficient for your feline friend (or friends). After all, it takes up space and nobody enjoys cleaning it.

The Mistake: Insufficient bathroom options create stress for cats, who are naturally clean and territorial animals.

The Fix: Follow the golden rule of paw: one litter box per cat, plus one extra. So if you have two cats, you should ideally have three litter boxes, preferably in different locations throughout your home. This prevents territorial disputes and gives your cats options if one box is occupied or not to their liking at the moment. Your floors (and furniture) will thank you for this simple change!

3. Ignoring the Litter Box

Speaking of litter boxes, how often are you scooping?

The Mistake: Many owners clean the litter box too infrequently. While it’s not the most glamorous task, neglecting it can lead to serious behavioral issues.

The Fix: Cats are fastidious creatures who value cleanliness above almost everything else. Scoop waste daily (twice daily in multi-cat households), and completely change the litter weekly. If the box stinks to you, imagine how it smells to your cat, whose sense of smell is 14 times stronger than yours! An unpleasant bathroom experience will quickly lead to your cat finding alternative—and likely unwelcome—places to do their business.

4. Neglecting Dental Care

When was the last time you took a good look at your cat’s teeth? Or better yet, brushed them?

The Mistake: Many cat owners completely overlook dental hygiene until serious problems develop. By age three, 70% of cats show signs of dental disease, which can lead to pain, infection, and even damage to internal organs.

The Fix: Start a dental routine that includes regular brushing with cat-specific toothpaste (never use human toothpaste!). If your cat won’t tolerate brushing, dental treats, water additives, and specially formulated dry food can help reduce plaque. Schedule regular dental check-ups with your veterinarian—catching problems early saves your cat pain and saves you money in the long run.

5. Not Cat-Proofing the Home

Cats are curious explorers who can navigate surprisingly small and high spaces—sometimes to their detriment.

The Mistake: Underestimating your cat’s ability to get into trouble with household items that seem harmless to us.

The Fix: Get down on all fours and view your home from your cat’s perspective. Secure dangling cords that could be chewed, remove toxic plants (lilies, aloe vera, and pothos are particularly dangerous), ensure window screens are secure, and put away small objects that could be swallowed. Also be mindful of seemingly innocent items like hair ties, string, dental floss, and plastic bags—all potential hazards if ingested. Taking these precautions can prevent emergency vet visits and keep your curious companion safe.

6. Assuming Purring = Happiness

That rumbling purr is always a sign of a content kitty, right? Not necessarily.

The Mistake: Interpreting purring as a universal sign of feline happiness and missing important cues about your cat’s actual state.

The Fix: Understand that cats also purr when in pain, anxious, or even when giving birth. Pay attention to context and body language that accompanies the purring. A happy cat will typically have relaxed whiskers, slow-blinking eyes, and loose body posture. A stressed or pained cat might purr while displaying tense muscles, flattened ears, or a tucked tail. Learning to read your cat’s complete body language will help you respond appropriately to their needs.

7. Punishing Instead of Redirecting

Your cat just knocked over your favorite vase, clawed the new sofa, or pounced on your feet at 3 AM. It’s frustrating, but how you respond matters immensely.

The Mistake: Reacting with punishment like spraying water, clapping loudly, or yelling at your cat.

The Fix: Cats don’t connect punishment with their behavior—they simply learn to fear you. Instead, redirect unwanted behavior to appropriate outlets. If your cat scratches furniture, provide appealing scratching posts and reward their use. For counter-jumping or destructive behavior, increase environmental enrichment with toys, climbing spaces, and regular play sessions. For early morning antics, schedule interactive play before bedtime to tire them out, and try automatic feeders that dispense food before your usual wake time. Positive reinforcement when your cat does something right is infinitely more effective than punishment when they do something wrong.

Taking Action: The One-Week Cat Enrichment Challenge

Ready to be a better cat parent? Here’s a simple activity to improve your relationship with your feline friend:

For the next 7 days, commit to implementing one improvement from this list each day:

Day 1: Respect boundaries day. Only pet your cat when they approach you, and stop when they show signs of overstimulation.

Day 2: Clean and assess your litter box situation. Add an extra box if needed, and establish a daily scooping routine.

Day 3: Examine your cat’s teeth and order dental supplies or make a vet appointment if needed.

Day 4: Cat-proof one room of your house completely, removing all potential hazards.

Day 5: Practice “cat reading” by observing your cat for 15 minutes and noting all body language and sounds without interacting.

Day 6: Replace one punishment response with redirection and positive reinforcement.

Day 7: Create one new enrichment activity for your cat—perhaps a puzzle feeder, a new climbing space, or a dedicated 10-minute play session.

At the end of the week, notice any changes in your cat’s behavior and your relationship. Small adjustments in how we interact with our feline companions can make an enormous difference in their wellbeing and happiness.

Remember, being a great cat parent isn’t about perfection—it’s about understanding and respecting our cats for the unique creatures they are, and continuously learning to better meet their needs.

Scroll to Top